Wednesday, October 29, 2014

The Penny Candy Shop

A small weathered building sits along Montauk Highway on the main drag in Water Mill. Its red door faded, paint peeling, a "For Sale" sign in the window. In faded black letters above the door the curling letters read "Penny Candy Shop". Sweet toothed shoppers no longer cross the threshold. The laughter of children and their parents a distant memory.
I stopped to take a closer look.
Inside, the shop is frozen in time.
An eerie quiet prevails.
Dust motes float in scant rays of sun slanting through the window.
Toys fading on the shelves.
Candy jars empty.
In the marvelous memoir, The Kingdom of the Kid: Growing up in the the Long-Lost Hamptons, Geoff Gehman devotes a chapter to the Penny Candy Shop and its founders June and Harvey Morris.
Excerpt from The Kingdom of the Kid by Geoff Gehman
June and Harvey became shopkeepers by accidental design. -- At the suggestion of his mother, they decided to open a store for crayons, coloring books and other basics for kids like Harvey Morris III, then seven years old. They decided to sell sweets because June had fond childhood memories of visiting a penny-candy store in Patchogue.

Harvey and June Morris, the shop's owners, had the gift of making kids feel like adults and adults like kids. They were gently funny, easily amused and eternally patient, traits that somehow slowed the wicked sugar rush of too may Hersey kisses or chunks of vanilla fudge. They were natural psychologists, sneaky sociologists, not-so-sneaky etiquette teachers, emergency chauffeurs, surrogate parents, capital-C citizens, dream weavers. Their store was the East End's most consistently miraculous place, where every day was Christmas, Easter, Halloween and your birthday. 

The Morrises opened for business on September 11, 1961 -- For 30 years it was open from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m. seven days a week for most of the year. They sold newspapers to potato farmers who needed to know the prices of their stock before 9 a.m. They sold candy bars to emergency workers during hurricanes. They could afford to stay open when most storekeepers stayed home because for 30 years they lived behind the shop.

The Penny Candy Shop in Water Mill was the spot for sweets and acts of sweet citizenship. - Geoff Gehman
The shop and home is for sale by owner here.
A time capsule of the long-lost Hamptons could be yours.
Geoff Gehman's book is available for immediate gratification here.


  1. Awesome post Gail. Love the photos and the history.

    1. I held my iPhone up against the window glass above the for sale sign and curtains and was delighted how they came out since I couldn't really see inside!

  2. Love this story, Gail. Thanks for sharing it.

    1. Thanks Judy, I was thinking of some of the abandoned building photos you have pinned.

  3. What a cute place!
    Years ago..I think I would have liked so cute..Watching a TV series called The Affair..the show says they are in Montauk..looks amazing.

  4. It is a darling shop even in its current down at heals state.

  5. The apartment was where my parents first lived when they married December 31, 1955. My father owned the building. The storefront was once a beauty parlor and then an antique store. My parents Eric & Lucille Corwith sold the building to Harvey & June Morris who made it the Penny Candy Store we all love and miss very much.

    1. Melissa, WOW thank you for your contribution regarding this building's wonderful history!

  6. My Grandfather, Pop Collum would take me there as a treat. It was a sweet time to spend together. Miss the old shops of the Hamptons.


Thank you for your comments!